Crafting a Winning AI Strategy: Avoiding the “We Need AI” Trap

Why AI Without a Plan is Just an Expensive Science Experiment

The boardroom buzz is deafening. The marketplace is full of banter about untold riches and opportunities.  Everyone is looking to be in on the latest trend in technology – Artificial Intelligence. 

"We need AI."

"AI will transform our business."

"We must stay ahead of the AI curve."

These statements sound bold, but in reality, they lack purpose and intent.  AI isn't a strategy. It's a tool—and a tool without a clear purpose is just an expensive science experiment. Saying "we need AI" is like saying "we need technology" or "we need digital transformation." It lacks intent, direction, and a clear path to value.  Overall, these are objectives at best, and need a cohesive strategy that ties them to expected beneficial outcomes.

Without an AI strategy, effort leads to wasted investments, misaligned teams, and projects that fizzle out before they deliver any positive results.  AI isn't magic. It won't fix broken processes, clean up messy data, or suddenly make your business more innovative. But with the right strategy, it can be a game-changer and put many of your most aggressive, ambitious goals over the top.

The “We Need AI” Trap: Why Companies Get AI Wrong

This is where businesses go off the rails. They confuse AI objectives with AI strategy. They think adopting AI is the goal when, in reality, AI should be a means to an end.  For example:

• AI Objective – A vague ambition, like: "We need AI to improve efficiency."

• AI Strategy – A structured, measurable, and intentional plan for how AI will create real business value.

The Harsh Reality: AI Objectives Alone Won’t Save You

I hear many CEOs and executives saying, "We need AI to automate processes." The challenge is they aren't asking the right questions to get the most out of AI.  What processes are we automating?  How will we measure success?  How will AI integrate into our existing workflows? Do we even have the correct data?

This line of conversation conveys the actual need – a cohesive AI strategy that is guided by expected outcomes.  Without it, you can be sure AI will do some things.  Those things may or may not even be positive, let alone aligned with clearly defined outcomes that fit your growth objectives.

AI Isn’t Magic – It Solves Problems (If You Know What Problem You’re Solving)

AI is only as good as the problem it's solving. If you can't clearly define the pain points AI will address, you're not ready for AI.  Knowing what problems you are looking to solve will help align the solutions you get with the expected beneficial outcomes.  Otherwise, you might end up with a solution that doesn't help.  For example, you can't expect an AI tool that produces PowerPoints to identify holes in your supply chain.  You may get some beautiful presentations, but your lead times will still be off.

Instead of asking, "How can we use AI?" start with, "What business problem are we solving?"

Real Life Use Cases:

• Are we losing customers due to slow response times? → AI-powered chatbots and automated support could help.

• Is inefficient inventory management eating into profits? → AI-powered predictive analytics could optimize supply chain decisions.

• Do we have too much manual work slowing us down? → AI-powered automation could eliminate repetitive tasks.

If your AI initiative has no clear, measurable business impact, it's just another IT vanity project.  After all, IT and AI are about creating value for the business to achieve its goals.

The 4 Pillars of AI Strategy

If you're serious about AI, you need a structured approach. These four pillars separate reality from the AI hype and focus on execution that leads to real business value.

1. Identify the Right Business Problem

AI shouldn't be just a shiny new toy—it should provide a solution to a real business problem. It's not a plug-and-play application. You need to know where your opportunities are and what might be broken, inefficient, or slow. Then, analyze the issues and ask what AI can do to either automate the process, make it smarter, reduce waste, or increase efficiency.

Real Life Use Cases:

• If your customer response times are too slow, AI-powered chatbots could reduce delays and handle high volumes of inquiries efficiently.

• If you have inventory management inefficiencies, AI-driven forecasting can effectively tighten your min/max inventory levels to ensure more just-in-time fulfillment.

• If you have issues with manual processes, AI can support automated workflows that include a more appropriate and efficient interaction.

Key Insight: AI can increase productivity by up to 40% through automation, but only when applied to well-defined, high-impact problems. Otherwise, the gains are either minimal or might even make things worse.

2. Ensure Data Readiness (Garbage In, Garbage Out)

AI is dependent on data. If your data is messy, inconsistent, or incomplete, AI won't fix the problem—it will amplify bad decisions faster than ever, the same way bad intel will drive smart people to make mistakes.

Think about it this way: if you're feeding AI bad information, you'll get bad outputs, poor decisions, and wasted resources.  And it will be harder to know why you got those bad results because AI logic can be difficult to follow as it is.

Real Life Use Cases:

• Feeding our chatbot inaccurate, incomplete, or irrelevant data and responses will cause it to give frustrating, unhelpful responses—either driving customers away or increasing phone calls to customer service. What was meant to save money ends up costing more in lost sales and damaged reputation.

• Forecasting inventory with AI based on flawed demand and sales data will create the wrong inventory levels. If the numbers aren't correct, AI might increase stockouts instead of preventing them or create excess inventory due to miscalculated demand.

• Using AI to automate workflows can be incredibly helpful, but if the steps themselves are not capturing the right data for human usage later on, then the automated process doesn't yield any benefit at all.

The bottom line? AI is only as good as the data it's built on. Before launching any AI initiative, start with a data audit. AI will fail if your data isn't structured, clean, and reliable.

Alternative Route: If you feel compelled to jump into AI as fast as possible and know your data is not good enough to support that – experts often recommend five years of good, clean, complete data – you can still use AI to begin learning and help clean up your data at the same time.  You might have a delay in full-scale launch, but you'll be farther along at launch time.

Key Insight: 75% of executives say data quality is the most critical factor in AI success. No clean data? No AI.  75% sounds like it's lower than it should be.

3. Define What Success Looks Like (Before You Write a Single Line of Code)

Saying AI will improve efficiency is meaningless unless you define what improvement actually looks like and how you can measure it on a real-time, continuous basis. So many AI initiatives struggle to prove ROI because no one defined what success looked like in the first place.

It might mean reducing operational costs by 10%, automating 30% of repetitive tasks, or cutting response times in half. Your goals may be wildly ambitious or seem crazy.  I'm less worried about what's achievable and more about defining a measurement to say, "Did we get there?"  If we didn't, we could ask, "Why not?" I'm okay with the answer being that we went too big.  Otherwise, we don't know how to close the gap if we don't get there.

Real Life Use Cases:

• A good goal for an AI chatbot could be to reduce response time by an exact number, like 50%—not just "improve customer service and cut costs."

• If you're investing in AI-driven inventory forecasting, defining success as a 10-15% decrease in excess stock or a 20% decrease in lead times are good, measurable goals. Don't just "optimize the supply chain."

• Automating workflows is similar. You might be tempted to say we're going to become more automated and leave it at that. However, you should target a certain number of processes or steps to eliminate through automation.

Key Stat: 75% of companies struggle to quantify AI ROI because they never define success upfront.

4. Align AI With Your Existing Tech Stack

AI doesn't operate in a vacuum. It has to integrate with your existing processes and applications to deliver real value. Knowing which ones are important as well—plugging an AI into an ERP and expecting it to deliver improvements in shop downtime may not yield the same kind of results as plugging into a more refined production planning system (unless your ERP has a robust one).

Imagine a company spending millions on AI-driven analytics, only to find out it doesn't sync with their ERP system. Now, instead of streamlining operations, it creates bottlenecks, requires workarounds, and slows everything down.

Make sure your AI automation project also accounts for human oversight. Automated processes that miss critical exceptions end up forcing employees to intervene constantly. Conversely, letting AI do too much before a human set of eyes gets a chance to make sure it seems solid can mask issues until they are bigger problems later.  Instead of AI making work easier, it ends up adding friction. Make sure you know which of your current systems your AI will integrate with, what new infrastructure you'll need, and who will own the AI tool and implementation itself. 

Real Life Use Cases:

• To be truly effective, AI chatbots need to pull data from existing customer interaction logs, CRM systems, and historical inquiries. Without integration, they're just an isolated tool with limited impact.

• AI-driven inventory management should be connected to ERP or WMS to sync forecasts and actual inventory levels. If it's not, AI predictions might never make it into operational workflows, rendering them useless.

• Workflows happen inherently inside applications, so automating them clearly needs to have a consistent, quality integration between your AI and the application that manages the workflow itself.

Key Stat: 50% of AI projects fail due to integration issues.

If You’re Thinking About AI, Let’s Talk

There’s no one-size-fits-all approach to AI strategy—every business is different. Whether you’re just starting your AI journey or refining your approach, the key is clarity, execution, and continuous improvement.

What are your thoughts?

💬 Have you seen AI initiatives succeed or fail in your industry?
💡 Are you facing challenges in defining your AI strategy?

If you’re looking for help with technology and are considering a change that isn’t just an upgrade, please reach out. We live and breathe this stuff and would be excited to listen, share an idea or two, or lend a helping hand.

Thank you for reading. Please comment with any insights, thoughts, and questions. If you have any questions you’d like to follow up on, please email us directly at info@theconfluencial.com. If you like what you see, follow us on LinkedIn and YouTube for more thought leadership weekly.